A critical review of all the parties that have achieved representation

An analysis of the AfD's victory in Saxony-Anhalt with a cross-cutting critique

EspDeu 9·07·2026 · 6:54 0

In the last few hours there has been a great stir surrounding a German political party, Alternative for Germany (AfD).

Don't look for the cause of what's happening in Germany in Moscow, but in Berlin and Brussels
Germany and the bias of talking about the 'extreme right' but not the 'extreme left'

Regional elections were held yesterday in the federal state of Saxony-Anhalt, in central Germany and in what was formerly the western part of East Germany. The official results can be found here. The AfD won a clear victory with 43.8% of the vote. The Christian Democratic Union of Germany (CDU) came in second with 17.2%, registering a sharp drop of 19.9 percentage points. The Social Democrats (SPD) came in third with 9.3% of the vote. The left-wing Greens (Die Grünen) came in fourth with 8.9%. The communists of Die Linke (The Left) obtained 8.6%, and their splinter group, the Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance (BSW), achieved 5.3%.

These elections have caused an electoral earthquake in Germany, as many media outlets claim it is the first time a far-right party (as the AfD is often labeled) has had a chance of governing a federal state since the Third Reich. Internationally, many media outlets are publishing headlines expressing outrage at this result, in many cases practically equating the AfD with the nazis.

I am a liberal-conservative and I don't identify with any of the parties that won seats yesterday in Saxony-Anhalt. I know this article will displease many, because it seems we've settled into the idea that you're either with one or the other, and I'm not with any of them. This gives me more freedom to say what I think about all the parties mentioned. If anyone sympathizes with any of them, I suppose they won't enjoy reading this, but above all, I'm driven by the defense of the truth, and I believe that many media outlets aren't telling it.

First of all, AfD is not a mazi party. As I already pointed out here two years ago, AfD co-chair Alice Weidel is a lesbian, her partner is a woman from Sri Lanka, and a href="https://archive.ph/Feyta" target="_blank">ten years ago she described herself as "liberal." She also publicly rejects antisemitismAfD openly supports the State of Israel. It's quite a strange profile for a person and a political party that some try to characterize as nazis.

In fact, that false labeling of AfD as nazi is the same clumsy strategy that the left has applied in other countries with parties that have a similar line to AfD, that is, a rather conservative program (you can read it here), which includes measures in favor of freedom of expression and birth rates, criticizes mass immigration and rejects abortion, political positions that are entirely legitimate in a democracy, even though the left intends to criminalize those who defend them. Labeling any conservative party as "nazi", "fascist" or "far right" only demonstrates the dishonesty of certain analysts, and in fact this contempt for the truth has ended up causing many voters, especially the younger ones (who are the least likely to follow traditional media) to ignore these crude demonizations.

Does that mean I like AfD? No. As I pointed out here two years ago, AfD is a pro-Russian party. Like other parties of that same ilk, AfD opposes sending military aid to Ukraine, rejects the sanctions on Russian gas and oil and advocates buying those resources from Russia. Four days after the start of the Russian invasion, on February 28, 2022, AfD called for Ukraine to be barred from NATO and the European Union and asked "to take into account Russia's legitimate security interests", in a clear alignment with the Kremlin that has not changed since then. I refuse to support any party that holds these positions, however much I agree with it on other things, because what AfD is doing with its pro-Russian attitude is favoring a terrorist regime that is invading a European country and systematically murdering civilians, including children and babies.

The most distressing aspect of yesterday's elections in Saxony-Anhalt is that three pro-Russian parties (AfD, Die Linke, and BSW) garnered 57.7% of the vote. Of course, these were regional elections, and the result cannot be extrapolated to the rest of Germany, but it is nonetheless a sad fact. Although Chancellor Friedrich Merz now seems determined to pursue a different course, I already warned here that the SPD and the CDU have for years engaged in a rapprochement with Russia, which materialized in the Nord Stream 1 and 2 gas pipelines, jointly promoted by both countries, leaving Eastern Europe at Putin's mercy. Former German Social Democratic Chancellor Gerhard Schröder, president of the SPD between 1999 and 2004 and one of the promoters of these gas pipelines, was elected president of the Nord Stream AG consortium in 2005 and ended up chairing the board of directors of the Russian state oil company Rosneft.

During her term, Christian Democrat Angela Merkel continued this pro-Russian line blocking Ukraine's entry into NATO in 2008, a blockade that facilitated Russia's annexation of Crimea in 2014 and large-scale Russian aggression against Ukraine in 2022. Thus, if there is a segment of the German electorate willing to give in to Russia, it is largely because the then main parties, the CDU and the SPD, aligned themselves shamefully with Russia, constantly ignoring the warnings of NATO's eastern partners (Poland, Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia) until it was too late.

On the other hand, and as I already pointed out here two years ago, the AfD's success is not due to Moscow, but to Brussels and Berlin. For many years, the CDU and the SPD have implemented social democratic, environmentalist, and pro-mass immigration policies that have ended up causing serious economic, social, and energy problems in Germany. AfD has capitalized on the discontent caused by these policies, and instead of addressing the root causes of the problems that have led to the party's rise, its rivals simply demonize it with the same old rhetoric, rhetoric that no longer works.

At this point, it's pointless to call a family "fascist" when they suffer in various ways from the consequences of the inept policies of the parties that hurl such accusations at their rivals. If the other parties want to stop the rise of the AfD, what they must do is correct the policies that have been impoverishing Germans for years, forcing citizens to endure exorbitant taxes, ruining Germany's powerful automotive sector, driving up electricity prices, fueling insecurity, and creating a dangerous Islamization of a segment of German society. The obvious question is: Do these parties know how to do anything different from what they've been doing until now?

Don't miss the news and content that interest you. Join Counting Stars for free on Telegram:

Opina sobre esta entrada:

You must login to comment. Click here to login. If you have not registered yet, you can create a user account here.

Contando Estrelas
Privacy Overview

Este sitio web utiliza cookies para ofrecerte la mejor experiencia de usuario posible. La información de las cookies se almacena en tu navegador y realiza funciones como reconocerte cuando vuelves a nuestro sitio web y ayudar a nuestro equipo a comprender qué secciones del sitio web te resultan más interesantes y útiles.